Selecting the right baby bottle seems easy until you try to shop for one yourself.
Suddenly, there are multiple bottle forms, nipple flows, anti-colic technologies, bottle sizes... and then there is the material question.
Should you choose a plastic or silicone baby bottle?
Plastic baby bottles have been a part of family lives for decades. They are light, known and widely available.
Silicone baby bottles have recently gained popularity among parents who look for a softer, flexible feeding option.
Does that make silicone bottles automatically better?
Certainly not for every family.
The right bottle is the one which suits your child's feeding needs along with your safety, cleaning and convenience requirements.
Here is a handy comparison to help you learn the differences between two bottle types.
To Start With, Why Is the Bottle Material Important?
The baby bottle is the item which is going to be used several times every day.
The milk stays inside it.
Parents frequently wash and sterilize it.
Kids may squeeze or chew its parts while playing.
That's why the material is certainly worth paying attention to.
While buying baby bottles, you should think not only about their looks but also:
- Material safety;
- Weight;
- Durability;
- Heat resistance;
- Cleaning;
- Grip;
- Feeding comfort;
- Long-term wear.
Let's compare plastic and silicone baby bottles separately.
What Are Plastic Baby Bottles?
The plastic baby bottles belong to the most widespread baby feeding bottles.
These bottles are usually made of light plastic material used in food or beverages.
One of the reasons why parents choose plastic baby bottles is their convenience.
They are usually:
- Light;
- Easy to transport;
- Hardly breakable after accidental dropping;
- Numerous in design and size variants.
For families who travel a lot or carry several bottles in a single diaper bag, weight is quite important.
However, not every plastic material is the same.
Always check the material of the bottle and the information about it which the manufacturer provides.
BPA in Plastic Baby Bottles – Do You Need to Be Concerned?
It is surely one of the first questions which you will be asked while researching plastic baby bottles.
Bisphenol A has been historically used in certain plastic products.
For that reason, when purchasing the plastic baby bottles, parents are advised to choose bottles which are definitely BPA-free and check manufacturer's material information.
According to HealthyChildren by the American Academy of Pediatrics, if you are concerned about your baby's BPA exposure, you should consider the bottles which are specifically marked as BPA-free.
Choosing the baby product should not imply guessing about its material.
Material information is important.
What Are Silicone Baby Bottles?
Silicone baby bottles are made out of soft and flexible material, namely, silicone itself which can be supplemented with other food-contact materials.
One of the differences becomes evident immediately after you pick up the bottle.
Unlike the rigid bottle, silicone has a soft and somewhat squeezable feeling.
Depending on the product design, silicone baby bottles can have the following properties:
- Soft body;
- Flexible design;
- Lightweight;
- Drop-resistant;
- Convenient grip;
- Less rigid feeling for a baby.
That's why silicone bottles have lately gained popularity among modern parents.
Plastic vs Silicone Baby Bottles – Quick Comparison
1. Feeling
Plastic bottles:
Firm and rigid.
Silicone bottles:
Soft and flexible.
For some kids, especially those who love holding and squeezing their bottles, the softer body of the silicone bottle is surely more convenient.
2. Weight
Both plastic and silicone bottles are relatively light in comparison with glass bottles.
That makes both of them convenient to:
- Carry during traveling;
- Transport in diaper bags;
- Feed at night;
- Take to daycare centers.
But the actual weight depends on each bottle design.
3. Drop Resistance
Babies drop everything.
All the time.
Just right after you picked it up.
Both materials have an advantage in this situation in comparison with breakable ones as they won't shatter after an ordinary fall.
Also, silicone is flexible and absorbs the impact while rigid bottles behave differently.
4. Grip
Most of the plastic baby bottles have a smooth and firm body.
Silicone has a naturally softer and more tactile body.
Once babies start to hold their bottles independently, grip becomes an important aspect.
But the bottle form is also significant.
5. Heat and Sterilization
Feeding bottles are supposed to be sterilized regularly and heated before feeding.
The heat resistance differs for every bottle as it depends on the manufacturer and material formula.
Never assume that every plastic or every silicone baby bottle has the same heat resistance level.
Always follow the sterilization and cleaning guidelines given with the bottle.
6. Durability
Quality plastic bottles will last long if you handle and clean them regularly and correctly.
But plastic bottles should be regularly checked for:
- Scratches;
- Cracks;
- Cloudiness;
- Warping;
- Surface wear.
Silicone bottles are flexible and not rigid.
That's why they don't scratch in the same way as the rigid material.
But they also should be checked regularly for cuts, tears or any other damages.
No matter what material you choose, a damaged feeding equipment should be changed.
7. Cleaning
Neither of the materials get automatically clean by any means.
The milk can accumulate inside the bottle, collar and nipple no matter of the material of the bottle body.
The bottle which is easy to disassemble is always easier to clean.
When choosing a bottle, check:
- Its number of parts;
- The bottle opening;
- The places where the milk can accumulate;
- Ease of reassembly.
Good bottle hygiene depends both on bottle design and material.
8. Comfort During Feeding
While the comfort during feeding depends not only on the bottle body material, but also on:
- Nipple shape;
- Nipple flow;
- Ventilation technology;
- The baby's feeding preferences.
Very good bottle body with the incorrect nipple flow can still make feeding very uncomfortable.
Some babies immediately get used to feeding from the bottle.
Other babies need more time.
And babies can be quite opinionated regarding the nipples they prefer.
What Is an Anti-Colic Bottle?
Sometimes you may find this term while comparing the bottles.
Anti-colic feeding bottle systems are usually designed to control the airflow and prevent the baby from swallowing air during feeding.
But the exact system differs from brand to brand.
If you see that your baby is uncomfortable after feeding, consulting your paediatrician might be a better idea than searching for the right bottle.
So, Is Silicone Better Than Plastic?
Silicone gives some practical advantages to those who prefer a feeding bottle which is:
- Soft;
- Flexible;
- Easy to grip;
- Light;
- Drop-resistant.
Plastic bottles have their advantages as well.
Good quality plastic bottles can serve well if you follow the manufacturer's requirements and care about your bottle.
That's why the main question is not:
"Is plastic bad and silicone good?"
A more useful question is:
"Which material and design suit the actual feeding of my baby?"
Why Do Some Parents Prefer Silicone Baby Bottles?
Imagine a common feeding scene.
The baby reaches for the bottle.
The fingers wrap around it.
The bottle drops.
It drops once again.
And the bottle drops...
Again.
This is just a part of baby life.
The silicone works well in these situations as it is naturally soft and flexible.
That's why it is comfortable to grip and gives you an opportunity to have the bottle body made out of another material besides rigid plastic.
In case you try to exclude the conventional plastic from the baby feeding products, silicone can be an excellent choice for you.
What Should You Consider While Buying Any Baby Bottle?
Bottle material is important, but it is not the only factor.
Before you purchase a bottle, consider the following aspects.
1. Material
The manufacturer should give clear information about the material of the baby bottle and feeding components.
2. Nipple Flow
The newborns require slow nipple flow while the other babies may require faster flow.
Choose the required flow and observe if your baby finds it convenient.
3. Anti-Colic Design
If this feature is essential for you, check the bottle ventilation system.
4. Bottle Size
Small bottles may be convenient for young babies, and the bigger capacity becomes needed later.
5. Cleaning
The fewer unnecessary crevices the bottle has, the easier it is to clean.
6. Grip and Design
Hold the bottle if possible.
The bottle can look beautiful online and be inconvenient to use during night feeding.
7. Material and Safety Information
Look for the clearly stated material and safety information.
Where Dodo Baby Silicone Feeding Bottles Fit In
At Dodo Baby we design our feeding products keeping the following reality in mind:
The baby bottle is frequently used.
It should work well during the night feeding, the hectic morning feeding, traveling and every situation when the baby decides to put the bottle on the floor.
Dodo Baby silicone feeding bottles are created in order to combine a comfortable, baby-friendly design with practical functionality.
Such features as baby-friendly nipple flows, anti-colic feeding system and carefully selected materials can help to make feeding more comfortable and convenient for the growing baby and his or her parents.
Because good baby products shouldn't only look cute on the shelf.
They should be comfortable at 2 a.m.
Should You Buy Silicone or Plastic Baby Bottle?
Choose depending on your family priorities.
The plastic baby bottle will suit you if you need something light and familiar.
The silicone baby bottle will suit you if you prefer soft, flexible bottle body, convenient to grip and resistant to accidental drops.
Some families can even use the both depending on the situation.
There is no rule stating that all bottles in your kitchen should be identical.
Conclusion
Plastic and silicone baby bottles are both suitable for baby feeding.
The main thing is to know what you buy.
In case you choose the plastic baby bottle, find the bottles which are made out of the BPA-free material and check them regularly for wear.
In case you prefer a soft and flexible feeding bottle, the silicone may be a good alternative.
The most important thing is to choose the bottle which your baby is comfortable with and which you can use without any problems every day.
Because when you prepare another bottle in the middle of the night, the best baby bottle is not the one which has the longest list of features.
It is the one which makes feeding easier.
Discover the Dodo Baby silicone feeding bottles made for comfortable everyday feeding – from newborn feeding to growing baby feeding.
About the Author
Written by Akrati Chaurasia, Founder of Dodo Baby. With 7+ years of experience in child development and EdTech education, Akrati is passionate about creating safe, thoughtfully designed baby products that make parenting easier. Dodo Baby is committed to premium, food-grade materials and honest guidance for modern parents.
Dodo Baby
Shop Dodo Baby's premium baby feeding products, including glass & silicone feeding bottles, feeding bowls, plates, spoons, sippy cups and more. Shop online in India.